Is Futures Trading Halal for Islamic Traders?

Futures present both opportunities and challenges for Muslim investors wishing to conduct their investing under Islamic financial principles. When answering the question, “Is futures trading Halal or Haram?” there is no absolute “Yes” or “No.” Rather, it depends on various factors, such as the futures contract in question, the style of trading, and the risks the investor takes.

Let’s take a deep dive into the world of futures, beginning with how the futures markets work and then Islamic financial principles to see how the two areas align.

Top Forex Brokers

1

Get Started 74% of retail CFD accounts lose money Read Review

What Is Futures Trading? 

Investors trade futures through “futures contracts.” Let’s examine this term first.

What Is a Futures Contract? 

A futures contract is a standardized legal contract to buy or sell something at a predetermined price for delivery at a specified time in the future. Let’s break down this definition into several aspects:

1. Standardization: Futures contracts trade through exchanges because they are standardized. For example, the “GCM30” contract is a Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) Gold futures contract for 1,000 troy ounces settling on June 26, 2030. Anyone trading the GCM30 contract will have the same specifications.
2. Expiration or delivery date: All futures contracts expire on a specified date. Before the expiration date, traders can close out or extend open positions without holding the trade to expiration. Some traders may choose to hold the contract and go to settlement.
3. Settlement: This fulfills the legal delivery obligations associated with the original contract. For some contracts, this delivery will be a physical delivery of the underlying commodity. For example, a food producer looking to acquire wheat may want to take delivery of physical wheat, and a farmer may want to deliver his wheat to that producer. Only a small percentage of future contracts are physically delivered.
4. Cash settlement: In most cases, delivery will be cash-settled, where settlement is a credit or debit for the value of the contract at its expiration. The most commonly cash-settled products are equity index and interest rate futures, although precious metals, foreign exchange, and some agricultural products may also be settled in cash.

Importantly, I can buy and sell any futures contract before expiration and before it goes to a physical settlement. Speculators generally do not want to acquire the underlying physical asset; instead, they want to profit from the change in its price.

What Are the Types of Futures Contracts? 

There are dozens of futures exchanges worldwide, but the largest is the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, which consists of four exchanges: CME, CBOT, NYMEX, and COMEX.

Futures markets fall into these main categories:      

1. Agriculture – e.g. corn, wheat, cocoa, soybean, sugar, cattle, milk, urea, and lumbar.
2. Cryptocurrency – e.g. Bitcoin and Ethereum
3. Currencies – e.g. Euro, Japanese Yen, British Pound, Australian Dollar, Canadian Dollar, Swiss Franc, New Zealand Dollar, Swedish Krona, and Norwegian Krona (all against the US Dollar).
4. Energy – e.g. crude oil, gasoline, ethanol, and natural gas. Also in this category are carbon emissions offset futures and even weather futures priced according to temperature variations.
5. Equity Indices – e.g. S&P 500, Nasdaq, Russell, Dow Jones, and Nikkei.
6. Fixed Income - used for hedging and speculating on bond prices.
7. Interest rate futures - futures contracts that are linked to the movement of interest rates.
8. Metals - gold, silver, platinum, copper, aluminum, ferrous (iron-based) metals, and battery metals such as cobalt and lithium.
9. Volatility Indices - volatility futures let traders speculate on future market volatility rather than direction.

Soft vs. Hard Commodities 

Agricultural commodities that must be grown are often known as soft commodities. Hard commodities include natural resources that must be mined or extracted, such as gold and oil.

Leverage and Margin in Futures 

Nearly all futures trading uses leverage, i.e., the ability to control a large contract value with a relatively small amount of capital, known as the margin.

• The initial margin is the amount the exchange requires to initiate a futures position. While the exchange sets the margin amount, a broker may require additional funds from the client.
• The maintenance margin is the minimum amount needed at any given time in the account for a trade to remain open.
• Margin calls. If the funds in a trading account drop below the maintenance margin, the broker may issue a “margin call,” requiring the client to add funds immediately to bring the account back up to the initial margin level. If the client does not meet the margin call, they must either reduce the position size to meet the margin call, or the broker may liquidate the position automatically.

Trading Futures with a Muslim (Swap-free) Account 

What Is a “Swap” in Trading? 

Some leveraged contracts pay or receive interest from the trader. For example, spot Forex typically has a swap for overnight positions, i.e., positions held after a specified cut-off time each trading day. Depending on the Forex pair, the broker credits or debits the trader’s account with an interest payment.

Swap-free Accounts 

Islamic or Sharia financial principles prohibit interest or Riba. Islam considers money to be a medium of exchange and not an actual asset. So, there must be an underlying exchange of goods or services when money changes hands, which does not happen with interest-based charges. To deal with the issue, the top Islamic brokers offer swap-free accounts, which either do not charge a swap or replace it with a flat fee as a service cost.

Futures trading does not necessarily have a swap or interest charge. The margin acts as collateral and is a cushion against potential losses if the market moves against the client’s position.

Is Futures Trading Halal or Haram? 

There are several sides to the debate. Let’s explore the different views.

Arguments that Futures Trading Is Haram 

1. Gharar (excessive uncertainty): Islamic finance prohibits excessive risk or uncertainty. Leverage heightens risk where a trader can lose their entire margin or account balance if a position moves against them.
2. Speculation and gambling: Futures trading normally does not require owning the underlying asset. This makes futures trading a speculative venture, closely resembling gambling, which is explicitly prohibited in Islam.
3. Lack of underlying assets: Interest rate, volatility and even weather-based futures lack tangible underlying assets. Islamic finance requires an underlying good or service for monetary transactions.

Arguments that Futures Trading Is Halal 

1. Gharar is capped: Futures markets minimize uncertainty or Gharar through exchange trading, which regulates execution, standardized contract terms and clear margin procedures.
2. Hedging benefits: Futures markets are essential for producers to hedge against price volatility, thereby managing financial risk, and speculators provide liquidity for that function. Overall, futures markets contribute to the stability and health of an economy, a goal consistent with Islamic financial objectives.
3. Futures trading differs from gambling: Gambling (forbidden under Islam) has no underlying assets. Certain futures markets, such as gold or equity index futures, are tied to underlying assets.

Why Is Futures Trading Limited for Muslim Traders? 

Shorting Futures 

There are two potential issues with short selling futures contracts for Muslim traders:

1. Unlimited risk or Ghara

Islam prohibits excessive risk. Shorting a futures contract theoretically exposes a trader to unlimited risk if the underlying asset's price increases sharply. In practice, most underlying markets in futures are liquid, and traders can exit futures positions with stop-losses. However, the possibility of a larger-than-expected loss is still there.

2. Profiting off a fall in value

Some Islamic scholars consider profiting off the fall in the price of an asset as un-Islamic.

If the Underlying Asset Is Haram 

Some underlying assets in futures contracts are considered inherently Haram, such as interest rates or pork, and most Islamic scholars believe Muslims should not trade them even if they regard other futures trading as Halal.

Sharia Principles that Futures Trading Should Follow 

1. Manage risk and avoid excessive Ghara. Use stop-losses, do not trade with excessive position sizes and have plenty of margin to contain risk.
2. Avoid Haram underlying assets. For example, do not trade interest rate or pork futures.
3. Stick to futures contracts with Halal underlying physical assets. For example, consider trading agricultural or soft commodities such as wheat, corn, soybeans, sugar, and cocoa and hard commodities such as gold, silver, and platinum.
4. Avoid interest charges on leveraged accounts, such as swap fees. Many brokers offer Islamic or swap-free accounts as an alternative to paying swap fees.

Bottom Line 

Futures markets present opportunities for Muslim investors, but whether they are Halal or Haram is nuanced and depends on several factors, including the underlying asset. An advantage of the futures market overall is that risk is managed through regulated exchanges and clear margin requirements, which aligns with Sharia principles. Futures contracts based on commodities or assets such as agricultural products, metals and equities are more in line with Sharia principles. Futures contracts based on Haram principles, such as interest rate futures, are generally considered forbidden under Islam.